A defense medical exam report can become a significant piece of evidence in a personal injury case. For plaintiff attorneys, reviewing that report carefully is essential because the physician’s conclusions may influence arguments involving causation, injury severity, treatment, functional limitations, future care, and damages.
But a DME report should not simply be accepted at face value.
The most useful review often involves comparing what the physician documented with the plaintiff’s medical records, reported symptoms, prior treatment, and—when available—an independent record of what actually occurred during the examination.
Here are several areas plaintiff attorneys should evaluate when reviewing a defense medical exam report.
1. Does the Medical History Match the Record?
Defense medical exam reports typically include a summary of the plaintiff’s medical history, injury, treatment, and current complaints.
This section should be reviewed closely.
Look for whether the report accurately reflects:
- The mechanism of injury
- Prior diagnoses
- Previous surgeries or injuries
- Treatment received
- Imaging findings
- Medications
- Ongoing symptoms
- Functional limitations
- Relevant pre-existing conditions
A report may contain omissions or wording that changes the context of the plaintiff’s medical history.
For example, a prior injury that fully resolved years earlier may be presented as a significant ongoing condition. Conversely, important treatment or diagnostic findings related to the current injury may receive little attention.
Comparing the DME report against the medical record can help identify whether the history has been presented completely and accurately.
2. Are the Plaintiff’s Statements Accurately Represented?
Statements made during a defense medical exam can become important later.
A physician may ask questions about pain levels, work capacity, daily activities, hobbies, exercise, sleep, or physical limitations.
When reviewing the report, compare the physician’s summary of those statements with what the plaintiff actually said.
There can be an important difference between:
“Patient can walk.”
and
“Patient can walk for approximately 15 minutes before significant pain begins.”
Both statements may technically be true, but they communicate very different levels of function.
An independent nurse observer can provide valuable documentation of the questions asked and the answers given during the examination.
3. Were the Tests Described in the Report Actually Performed?
Defense physicians may document a wide range of physical, neurological, orthopedic, or functional tests.
When reviewing the final report, plaintiff attorneys should note which tests are listed and whether there is documentation showing how those tests were performed.
Questions to consider include:
- Was the test performed at all?
- Was it performed on both sides?
- Was an instrument used?
- Was the result measured or visually estimated?
- Was the test repeated?
- Did the plaintiff report pain?
- Did the examiner physically assist with the movement?
These details may be particularly important in orthopedic, neurological, or chronic pain cases.
4. Are Range-of-Motion Findings Supported?
Range-of-motion measurements frequently appear in defense medical exam reports.
These findings may later be used to support conclusions about impairment, recovery, or functional ability.
Attorneys should review how range of motion was documented.
Consider whether the report explains:
- How measurements were obtained
- Whether a goniometer or other instrument was used
- Whether movement was active or passive
- Whether pain occurred during testing
- Whether the physician repeated measurements
A numerical measurement may appear precise, but its reliability depends on how the examination was actually conducted.
5. Are Pain Responses and Limitations Included?
Pain is inherently subjective, but that does not make it irrelevant.
During a DME, a plaintiff may report pain with movement, tenderness, weakness, numbness, or difficulty completing certain maneuvers.
Those reactions may—or may not—appear in the final report.
Attorneys should look for whether the report accurately documents:
- Pain during testing
- Inability to complete a maneuver
- Guarding
- Difficulty changing positions
- Altered gait
- Weakness
- Fatigue
- Limited movement
Omitting these observations can create an incomplete picture of the examination.
6. Does the Report Distinguish Objective Findings From Opinion?
A defense medical exam report may include both examination findings and the physician’s professional conclusions.
Those are not the same thing.
For example:
“Patient demonstrated 90 degrees of shoulder flexion.”
is a documented finding.
“The patient has no significant functional impairment.”
is a medical opinion.
Attorneys should distinguish between objective observations, plaintiff-reported symptoms, and the physician’s interpretation of those findings.
This distinction can be especially important when reviewing opinions regarding causation, prognosis, future treatment, or work restrictions.
7. How Does the Physician Address Causation?
Causation is often a central issue in personal injury litigation.
A DME physician may conclude that the plaintiff’s symptoms are caused by:
- A pre-existing condition
- Degenerative changes
- A prior injury
- Age-related changes
- Another medical condition
- The incident at issue
- A combination of factors
When reviewing this section, consider whether the physician explains the reasoning behind the conclusion.
Does the opinion address imaging, treatment history, symptom onset, prior records, and changes in function after the incident?
A conclusion is stronger when it is supported by a clear medical rationale rather than a generalized statement.
8. Does the Report Address the Plaintiff’s Complete Treatment History?
Plaintiffs with significant injuries may have extensive medical records.
A defense medical examiner may review only part of that history.
Attorneys should compare the records referenced in the report with the full medical file.
Important records may include:
- Emergency department records
- Imaging studies
- Operative reports
- Physical therapy
- Pain management
- Specialist evaluations
- Prior medical records
- Diagnostic testing
- Follow-up care
Understanding what the examiner did—and did not—review can provide important context for the opinions offered.
9. Does the Report Match the Length and Scope of the Examination?
A DME report may describe numerous tests, extensive history taking, and detailed physical findings.
The actual examination may have lasted a relatively short period of time.
Documenting the start and end time of the exam can provide useful context.
If the report describes an extensive examination, attorneys may want to compare that description with the independent record of what occurred.
10. Are There Internal Inconsistencies?
Sometimes discrepancies exist within the report itself.
For example, one section may state that the plaintiff has limited movement while another describes normal function.
The report may acknowledge abnormal imaging but later state that there is no objective basis for symptoms.
Review the document as a whole and look for areas where the findings, history, and conclusions do not align.
Why Independent DME Documentation Matters
An independent record of the defense medical exam can give attorneys another point of comparison when the physician’s report is received.
A legal nurse consultant can document:
- Start and end times
- Questions asked
- Plaintiff responses
- Tests performed
- Range-of-motion testing
- Pain responses
- Functional observations
- Other relevant events during the exam
This documentation does not determine whether a physician’s opinion is correct. It provides attorneys with additional factual context when reviewing the final report.
Nutris Legal Nurse Consultants Supports Plaintiff Attorneys
At Nutris Legal Nurse Consultants, we provide professional nurse observation of defense medical examinations and other legal nurse consulting services for plaintiff attorneys.
Our nurses create detailed, objective documentation of what occurs during the examination so legal teams can compare the actual exam with the physician’s final report.
When a defense medical exam could influence key issues in a case, accurate documentation matters.
Contact Nutris Legal Nurse Consultants to learn more about DME observation and litigation support services.



Leave a Reply